In this paper, the widely-used variance-based method (Sobol') and the recently proposed moment-independent PAWN method for GSA are applied to the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), and compared in terms of ranking and screening results of 26 SWAT parameters. In order to set a threshold for parameter screening, we propose the use of a “dummy parameter”, which has no influence on the model output. The sensitivity index of the dummy parameter is calculated from sampled data, without changing the model equations. We find that Sobol' and PAWN identify the same 12 influential parameters but rank them differently, and discuss how this result may be related to the limitations of the Sobol' method when the output distribution is asymmetric.","AbstractOtherLang":null,"BibLvlCode":"AS","StandardTitle":"Comparison of variance-based and moment-independent global sensitivity analysis approaches by application to the SWAT model","OrigTitleLangCode":"en","OrigTitleLangCodeExtended":"eng","OrigTitleLangID":15,"DateLastModified":{"date":"2026-06-07 01:38:20.059688","timezone_type":1,"timezone":"+02:00"},"UserAccessRight":null,"UserAccID":null,"AuthorKeywords":"Global sensitivity analysis;Moment-independent method; Variance-based method; PAWN; Sobol'; SWAT","OtherDescriptors":null,"Notes":null,"AnaPub":2017,"MonPub":null,"DateUpdate":"2018-04-11","DateCreate":"2017-02-22","SecASFANote":null,"ConfID":null,"PeerRev":1,"VlizCoreFlag":0,"WoScode":"WOS:000399868000015","VABBcode":null,"OpenAcc":0,"DOI":"10.1016/j.envsoft.2017.02.001"},"refs":null,"anarec":{"AnaID":283603,"PubliDate":2017,"Pagination":"210-222","XtraPublOfAnaID":null,"ISBN":null,"Volume":"91","Issue":null,"BRefMon":null,"BRefMonRR":null,"BRefXtra":null,"BRefXtraRR":null,"SerBRefID":123438,"SerRR":"Environmental Modelling & Software. Elsevier: Oxford. ISSN 1364-8152; e-ISSN 1873-6726","StandardTitleSer":"Environmental Modelling & Software","ISSN":"1364-8152","AbbrevSer":"Environ. Model. Softw.","StandardTitleMon":null,"StartPage":210,"Pages":13,"ToPubliDate":null,"BRefBibLvlCode":"S","SerNotes":null},"monrec":null,"serrec":null,"relations":null,"relationsRev":null,"addrec":null,"othpubs":null,"ownerships":null,"authors":[{"AutName":"Khorashadi Zadeh","Firstname":"Farkhondeh","Initials":"F.","Affiliation":null,"Discriminator":null,"CorporateFlag":0,"BEntID":275621,"AutID":194078,"OrderNr":1,"DegrID":null,"EditorFlag":0,"CorrespFlag":0,"IllustratorFlag":0,"ReviserFlag":0,"TranslatorFlag":0,"InsAcronym":null,"InsFSN":null,"ORCID":null,"PersID":null,"InsID":null},{"AutName":"Nossent","Firstname":"Jiri","Initials":"J.","Affiliation":null,"Discriminator":null,"CorporateFlag":0,"BEntID":275621,"AutID":189890,"OrderNr":2,"DegrID":null,"EditorFlag":0,"CorrespFlag":0,"IllustratorFlag":0,"ReviserFlag":0,"TranslatorFlag":0,"InsAcronym":"WL","InsFSN":"Vlaamse overheid; Beleidsdomein Mobiliteit en Openbare Werken; Vlaams Ministerie Mobiliteit en Openbare Werken; Departement Mobiliteit en Openbare Werken; Waterbouwkundig Laboratorium","ORCID":"0000-0002-4155-3002","PersID":12186,"InsID":116},{"AutName":"Sarrazin","Firstname":"Fanny","Initials":"F.","Affiliation":null,"Discriminator":null,"CorporateFlag":0,"BEntID":275621,"AutID":194079,"OrderNr":3,"DegrID":null,"EditorFlag":0,"CorrespFlag":0,"IllustratorFlag":0,"ReviserFlag":0,"TranslatorFlag":0,"InsAcronym":null,"InsFSN":null,"ORCID":null,"PersID":null,"InsID":null},{"AutName":"Pianosi","Firstname":"Francesca","Initials":"F.","Affiliation":null,"Discriminator":null,"CorporateFlag":0,"BEntID":275621,"AutID":194080,"OrderNr":4,"DegrID":null,"EditorFlag":0,"CorrespFlag":0,"IllustratorFlag":0,"ReviserFlag":0,"TranslatorFlag":0,"InsAcronym":null,"InsFSN":null,"ORCID":null,"PersID":null,"InsID":null},{"AutName":"Van Griensven","Firstname":"Ann","Initials":"A.","Affiliation":null,"Discriminator":null,"CorporateFlag":0,"BEntID":275621,"AutID":39453,"OrderNr":5,"DegrID":null,"EditorFlag":0,"CorrespFlag":0,"IllustratorFlag":0,"ReviserFlag":0,"TranslatorFlag":0,"InsAcronym":null,"InsFSN":null,"ORCID":"0000-0002-2105-6287","PersID":2702,"InsID":null},{"AutName":"Wagener","Firstname":"Thorsten","Initials":"T.","Affiliation":null,"Discriminator":null,"CorporateFlag":0,"BEntID":275621,"AutID":64173,"OrderNr":6,"DegrID":null,"EditorFlag":0,"CorrespFlag":0,"IllustratorFlag":0,"ReviserFlag":0,"TranslatorFlag":0,"InsAcronym":null,"InsFSN":null,"ORCID":null,"PersID":null,"InsID":null},{"AutName":"Bauwens","Firstname":"Willy","Initials":"W.","Affiliation":null,"Discriminator":null,"CorporateFlag":0,"BEntID":275621,"AutID":189889,"OrderNr":7,"DegrID":null,"EditorFlag":0,"CorrespFlag":0,"IllustratorFlag":0,"ReviserFlag":0,"TranslatorFlag":0,"InsAcronym":"HYDR","InsFSN":"Vrije Universiteit Brussel; Faculteit Toegepaste Wetenschappen; Vakgroep Hydrologie en Waterbouwkunde","ORCID":null,"PersID":2699,"InsID":790}],"mapdetails":null,"datasets":null,"monographs":null,"monparts":null,"serparts":null,"BEntOpen":null,"BEntPrivate":null,"availability":[{"BInstID":299677,"LibID":2706,"BRefID":283603,"EmbargoDate":null,"FullEmbargoDate":null,"PhysMedID":16,"hasOCRd":null,"ShelfLocCode":"299677","RFID":null,"PaidValue":null,"Medium":"Server","Description":"Dig. documenten die iedereen binnen het WL kan raadplegen","Acronym":"WL","Library":"Waterbouwkundig Laboratorium","DutchTerm":null,"URL":null,"ClassifID":221,"Classification":"Non-open access","ReqLink":1,"ClassifTypID":3,"URLLocation":"https://vlaamseoverheid.sharepoint.com/sites/dmow_a_imisdata/IMIS intern/","SubDir":0,"InternalReq":1,"LoggedInReq":null,"Disclaimer":"Disclaimer_WL_Int","DutchDisclaimer":null,"FileFormat":".pdf","FileDescr":"pdf","InsPub":1,"InsID":116,"FileFormID":6,"LendableFlag":null,"PublicFlag":1,"orderLib":"Waterbouwkundig Laboratorium","Notes":null,"AccConID":null,"AccessConstraint":null,"LicURL":null}],"litstyles":null,"thespers":null,"arch2discl":null,"SERpubls":[{"PublName":"Elsevier","City":"Oxford"}],"MONpubls":null,"pictures":[],"thestermsPath":null,"thestermsASFA":null,"taxtermsASFA":null,"geotermsASFA":null,"collections":[{"Collection":"Waterbouwkundig Laboratorium","ShortName":"WL"}],"conf":null,"proj":null,"Physdatasets":null,"spcols":{"892":{"SpName":"waterbeheer","SpColID":892,"ParSpColID":130,"TopParID":130,"ShortName":null,"URLLocation":null,"LibID":2706,"OpenRepoFlag":null,"SpTypID":null,"TopParIDNotWebsite":null,"SpColPath":"WL/waterbeheer"},"130":{"SpName":"Waterbouwkundig Laboratorium","SpColID":130,"ParSpColID":null,"TopParID":null,"ShortName":"WL","URLLocation":null,"LibID":2706,"OpenRepoFlag":null,"SpTypID":1,"TopParIDNotWebsite":null,"SpColPath":"WL"},"1025":{"SpName":"WL expert","SpColID":1025,"ParSpColID":null,"TopParID":null,"ShortName":"WL expert","URLLocation":null,"LibID":null,"OpenRepoFlag":null,"SpTypID":null,"TopParIDNotWebsite":null,"SpColPath":"WL expert"},"360":{"SpName":"WL Staf Publicaties","SpColID":360,"ParSpColID":130,"TopParID":130,"ShortName":"wl stafpublicaties","URLLocation":null,"LibID":null,"OpenRepoFlag":null,"SpTypID":null,"TopParIDNotWebsite":null,"SpColPath":"WL/wl stafpublicaties"}},"doi":null,"publs":null,"serparttypes":null,"monauthors":null,"MParts":null,"SParts":null,"hLibs":null,"langs":[{"BEntID":275621,"AbstractFlag":0,"LangID":15,"LangCode":"en","Lang":"English","DutchTerm":"Engels","LangCodeExtended":"eng"},{"BEntID":275621,"AbstractFlag":1,"LangID":15,"LangCode":"en","Lang":"English","DutchTerm":"Engels","LangCodeExtended":"eng"}],"urls":[{"URL":"https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2017.02.001","externalID":"10.1016/j.envsoft.2017.02.001","URLTypeCode":"DOI","URLID":63876,"URLTypID":13,"URLType":"DOI","URLPrefix":"http://dx.doi.org/"}],"thesterms":null,"taxterms":null,"geoterms":null,"othterms":null,"asfacodes":null,"asfa2codes":null,"thestermsFRIS":null,"taxtermsFRIS":null,"geotermsFRIS":null,"othtermsFRIS":null,"resmessage":"","complete":1,"sessions":{"newSesName":"Cerpentier, Steven, S.","newSesDate":{"date":"2017-02-22 10:08:48.580000","timezone_type":3,"timezone":"Europe/Brussels"},"updSesName":"Cerpentier, Steven, S.","updSesDate":{"date":"2018-04-11 11:26:38.923000","timezone_type":3,"timezone":"Europe/Brussels"}}}