Document of bibliographic reference 396416

BibliographicReference record

Type

Bibliographic resource

Type of document

Journal article

BibLvlCode

AS

Title

Empirical evidence of alternative stable states in an estuary

Abstract

Due to human activity, ecosystems are exceeding their ecological thresholds and shifting into undesired alternative stable states with new ecological configurations. Despite their purported ubiquity, it is uncertain whether estuaries can exist in multiple stable states. We use data from a 3.5-year study of invertebrate communities in an Australian estuary that is usually closed to the ocean to test for their existence. Sampling spanned a 1.5-year period of hypersalinity (>40 ppt) during a prolonged estuary closure, where salinity reached 122 ppt, and for two years during and after the estuary opened to the ocean when salinities were mesohaline (5–19 ppt). Two distinct community states occurred before and after the sandbar breached, with an intermediary period of invertebrate community impoverishment due to sediment scouring. During the closure, the community was simple (average of one taxa 100 cm⁻²) and dominated by larvae of terrestrial insects, most notably the halotolerant, non-biting midge Tanytarsus barbitarsis. After opening, the richness and abundance of invertebrates increased (average of four taxa and 84 individuals 100 cm⁻²) as polychaetes, molluscs and crustaceans colonised the estuary, although recovery was incomplete according to previous species records. Duration of estuary closure and salinity were the strongest drivers of composition. This study, together with evidence from the literature, suggests a salinity threshold of 60–65 ppt between states. These empirical data meet key criteria of alternative states, i.e. a clear transition between two distinct self-sustaining communities, indicating a regime shift triggered by an exogenous event. Our findings suggest that temporarily open and closed estuaries can exist in alternative stable states, with prolonged closures, hypersalinity, and sandbar breaching being key determinants of the switch between states. This situation may apply to other low-inflow estuarine systems, particularly in arid, semi-arid, or seasonally arid climates, and may become more frequent with human-induced climate change.

Bibliographic citation

Cronin-O'Reilly, S.; Krispyn, K.N.; Maus, C.; Standish, R.J.; Loneragan, N.R.; Tweedley, J.R. (2024). Empirical evidence of alternative stable states in an estuary. Sci. Total Environ. 954: 176356. https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.176356

Is peer reviewed

true

Access rights

open access

Is accessible for free

true